The Malaysian Journal of Soil Science (MJSS) greatly appreciates the valuable contributions of reviewers in maintaining the quality, integrity, and scientific standards of the journal.

Reviewers are requested to evaluate manuscripts objectively, constructively, and confidentially based on the following criteria:

---

Review Criteria

Reviewers should assess:

• Relevance to the aims and scope of the journal.
• Originality and scientific contribution of the work.
• Soundness of the research methodology and experimental design.
• Quality and reliability of data analysis and interpretation.
• Adequacy of references and engagement with relevant literature.
• Clarity, organisation, and quality of presentation.
• Validity of conclusions and recommendations.

---

Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are expected to:

• Maintain strict confidentiality regarding all manuscript contents.
• Provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based comments.
• Identify relevant published work that has not been cited.
• Alert the editor to possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, ethical concerns, or scientific misconduct.
• Complete reviews within the requested timeframe.
• Refrain from using information obtained through peer review for personal advantage.

---

Conflict of Interest

Reviewers should decline review invitations if they have any financial, professional, institutional, collaborative, or personal relationships that could influence their assessment of the manuscript.

---

Recommendations

Reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:

• Accept
• Minor Revision
• Major Revision
• Reject

The final publication decision remains the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief.